Is college really a scam? Is the wool being pulled over our overly-educated eyes? I’ve been thinking about this lately.
I know I personally qualify as a member of the overly-educated American middle class. I have a Bachelor’s and a Master’s degree. And I ask myself daily, from a financial perspective, what is it all good for?
This especially happens when I see someone on Facebook, someone who I went to high school with, who is of average intelligence and has little ambition. Said person has only a high school degree or an associate’s degree. S/he lives in a beautiful house with either a rich spouse, or s/he works a very average job … and still makes more money than I do. This leaves me scratching my head and thinking, what was I thinking?
I feel very closely attuned to the college graduates of today, who question their choice in getting a degree. Thousands upon thousands of dollars in loan debt, and without a job, it’s hard to find the silver lining of the year 2000 Clinton economy.
Not only do I question this, but so does finance expert James Altucher of DailyFinance AOL. In his article entitled Seven Reasons Not to Send Your Kids to College he lists 7 reasons of why college is a scam. The one reason that really caught my eye was:
The cost of the average college tuition has gone up nine-fold since 1976 versus seven-fold for health care and three-fold for inflation.
I was pretty shocked by this fact, especially in comparison to health care.
Altucher goes on to say instead of paying for college, parents should give kids $20K to start one of five businesses. Or they can travel the world, work, volunteer and do nothing but read.
OK. I agree with taking a gap year. I really wanted to do so, but my father was near retirement and turned down the idea, which is understandable. I agree with working for a while, especially if the kid is not ready or mature enough for college. I agree with volunteering for Habitat for Humanity or another organization.
I do not agree with $20K for a new business. Even the best businessmen and women with MBAs from the best schools have businesses that fail. Donald Trump declared bankruptcy. So just giving $20K to an 18-year old who knows nothing about overhead, capital, profit margin, start-up costs … and doesn’t even know what these terms mean sounds like a terrible idea. One of the worst I’ve ever heard.
I also do not agree with “do nothing but read.” That’s fine if you want to be the next Jack Kerouac, but if your interests lie in science or technology, where can you just go into a lab and conduct experiments? The equipment alone, glassware and simple measuring devices in a biology or chemistry lab can easily cost over $1000. Plus, the chemicals you can’t purchase unless you’re connected with a school. I won’t even go into graphic design …
I’ve saved the best part for last. I looked up Mr. Altucher’s background. Apparently, he has a Bachelor’s from Cornell University and a Master’s from Carnegie Mellon University.
Do as I say, not as I do.
I’m certainly not saying Mr. Altucher is wrong. After all, he is a financial expert with degrees from prestigious schools and he makes excellent points. But some of his suggestions come off a little like Kanye West, a rapper who urges children not to go to college.
What do you think? Is college a scam? Please let us know.
Please read what financial expert Peter Schiff has to say on this subject.
~ the WPC team
© White Picket College, 2010 – College Funding for the Upper Middle Class